| Chat Guest | Team | Date | Position |
| December 2005 | |||
| David Wright | Mets | 12/15 | 1B |
| Dan Johnson | A's | 12/9 | 3B |
| November 2005 | |||
| Ned Colletti | Dodgers | 11/29 | GM |
| October 2005 | |||
| Doug Melvin | Brewers | 10/20 | GM |
| September 2005 | |||
| Dennis Eckersley | HOF | 9/12 | RHP |
| Alex Rodriguez | Yankees | 9/8 | 3B |
| August 2005 | |||
| Duke Snider | Dodgers | 8/23 | OF |
| Rickie Weeks | Brewers | 8/23 | 2B |
| Phil Garner | Astros | 8/16 | Manager |
| Carl Erskine | Dodgers | 8/8 | RHP |
| Tim Purpura | Astros | 8/1 | GM |
| July 2005 | |||
| Mark Attanasio | Brewers | 7/28 | Owner |
| Don Newcombe | Dodgers | 7/25 | RHP |
| Johnny Podres | Dodgers | 7/11 | LHP |
| Duke Snider | HOF | 7/7 | CF |
| June 2005 | |||
| Cesar Izturis | Dodgers | 6/28 | SS |
| George Brett | HOF | 6/28 | 3B |
| Logan White | Dodgers | 6/16 | Scouting director |
| Jack Zduriencik | Brewers | 6/9 | Scouting director |
| Lyle Overbay | Brewers | 6/2 | 1B |
| May 2005 | |||
| Jim Tracy | Dodgers | 5/20 | Manager |
| Bobby Doerr | HOF | 5/20 | 2B |
| April 2005 | |||
| Milton Bradley | Dodgers | 4/27 | OF |
| Jeff Cirillo | Brewers | 4/21 | 3B |
| Ray King | Cardinals | 4/20 | LHP |
| Doug Melvin | Brewers | 4/07 | GM |
| Bob Feller | HOF | 4/06 | RHP |
| March 2005 | |||
| Michael Cuddyer | Twins | 3/31 | 3B |
| Gorman Thomas | Brewers | 3/31 | Former player |
| Brian Jordan | Braves | 3/29 | OF |
| Doug Davis | Brewers | 3/24 | LHP |
| Chris Capuano | Brewers | 3/17 | LHP |
| Mark Attanasio | Brewers | 3/10 | Owner |
| Dale Petroskey | HOF | 3/8 | President |
| February 2005 | |||
| Jerry Coleman | HOF | 2/25 | Frick Award winner |
| Terry Ryan | Twins | 2/23 | GM |
| Dan Kolb | Braves | 2/23 | RHP |
| Paul DePodesta | Dodgers | 2/23 | GM |
| Peter Gammons | HOF | 2/9 | Writer/Analyst |
| Ryne Sandberg | HOF | 2/2 | 2B |
| January 2005 | |||
| Tim Hudson | Braves | 1/26 | RHP |
| Wade Boggs | HOF | 1/25 | 3B |
| Kevin Millwood | Indians | 1/13 | RHP |
Fan Forum